| Boxing Metrics | BoxRec | The Ring | Boxing Only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inoue | Inoue | Usyk | Usyk |
| Usyk | Usyk | Inoue | Inoue |
| Crawford | Stevenson | J Rodriguez | Stevenson |
| Stevenson | J Rodriguez | Bivol | Bivol |
| Alimkhanuly | Benavidez | Beterbiev | J Rodriguez |
| Bivol | Nakatani | Nakatani | Alvarez |
| Opetaia | Crawford | Stevenson | Beterbiev |
| Alvarez | Alvarez | Benavidez | Gervonta |
| J Rodriguez | Haney | Haney | Nakatani |
| Benavidez | Ennis | Collazo | Benavidez |
(I hope this works. I’ve never made a table in the forum before. 
)
So anyway, we normally dis p4p lists. But we also can’t resist taking more than a few peeks at them. They’re also good for discussion.
I actually wanted to include a 5th source, but the table would only accept four columns. Oh well… the source I left out was Boxing P4P. They had Canelo 3rd, so I automatically threw them out. 
Interesting seeing the discrepancies in the lists. The Ring’s is the oldest (Jan 15th), but I won’t hold that against them. So I found some interesting things…
Obviously, Inoue and Usyk were either #1 or #2 on everyone’s list. (Well, Usyk was 11th on Boxing P4P’s list, which is another reason I threw them out. Canelo at #3, and Usyk 11th?? Hell… a 10-year old could come up with a better list).
I liked that Oscar Collazo snuck in at #10 on The Ring’s list. Little guys need some love too. 
Crawford is treated badly by these lists. #3 in Boxing Metrics, but #7 with BoxRec, and outside the top 10 in The Ring and Boxing Only. Don’t agree with that.
What other observations do you have?